JBL GTO 804 or Polk MM840
Even if your subwoofer is not blown, this is a good, inexpensive upgrade:
JBL GTO804 Reduced Depth 8-Inch Subwoofer
It works well with the factory amp, and it sounds much tighter than the factory driver. Organ pipes sound like organ pipes, and base fiddles sound like base fiddles, instead of vague thumps. The JBL is also more efficient.
However, do not get this driver (or any other upgraded 8 inch subwoofer) expecting an easy and quick substitution. The factory enclosure must be modified to accept the added depth of this subwoofer and many others. Also, the speaker mounting holes do not quite line up. The factory enclosure has a molded platform that permits an additional mounting screw into the center of the subwoofer magnet. To mount the deeper JBL, I had to cut an inch off this platform and reseal the enclosure using a steel plate, about 10 3/4" screws and half a tube of silicon. I redrilled the speaker mounting holes to match the new driver, and attached the JBL using #8 T-nuts held in place with plastic epoxy and #8 machine screws. Lastly, I had to remove some of the damping material from the eclosure to accommodate the much larger magnet on the JBL.
The improved sound made all of this work worthwhile, but I have subsequently realized that there might be an easier way to do it. There is a full inch of clearance between the subwoofer and the speaker grill, and the whole procedure might be done using an adapter ring at the front of the enclosure. I would probably use polycarbonate sheet like Lexan to make the ring.
The mounting depth of the factory driver is 3 1/2", and the mounting depth of the JBL GTO804 is 4 5/16", for a difference of 13/16". So, a 3/4" adapter ring with a 1/16" gasket would work, provided the enclosure did not rattle against the back of the magnet.
A 3/4" adapter ring would definitely work with the Polk Audio MM840. It uses a more powerful and compact neodymium magnet that gives the driver a 4 1/8" mouting depth.
I wish I had thought of these things before I embarked on the project. Oh, well.
My next upgrade will be to replace the amp with Rockford Fosgate R500-1D, witch supplies 250 watts RMS into 4 ohms. It is about the same size as the factory amp and will mount transparently.
And then, I will probably need a 10" subwoofer in order truly to scare passengers with the cannon shots in the 1812 Overature. It never ends.